South Siesta resident appeals Circuit Court dismissal of lawsuit filed to try to prevent operation of Avenue B and C stoplight

Wallace asserts that he does have ‘standing’ to pursue litigation

This is a Kimley-Horn of Sarasota engineering drawing showing plans for the stoplight at Avenue B and C, dating to 2021. Image courtesy FDOT

South Siesta Key resident James P. Wallace III has filed an appeal of a 12th Judicial Circuit Court judge’s dismissal of Wallace’s latest legal attempt to try to prevent the operation of a traffic signal at the intersection of Stickney Point Road and Avenue B and C, The Sarasota News Leader has learned.

During the Sarasota County Commission’s regular meeting on July 7, County Attorney Joshua Moye reported that Circuit Judge Hunter W. Carroll sided with the county in dismissing the case on June 15, agreeing with the county’s argument that Wallace did not have “standing” to pursue the litigation.

As Cornell Law School’s Legal Information Institute explains, “Standing, or locus standi, is the capacity of a party to bring a lawsuit in court. To have standing, a party must demonstrate a sufficient connection to and harm from the law or action being challenged.”

For years, Wallace has maintained that if the traffic signal became operational, it “would adversely impact emergency medical and fire vehicle travel times to and from Siesta Key,” a June 18 memo from the Office of the County Attorney (OCA) pointed out.

That memo, which was included in the County Commission’s agenda packet for its July 7 meeting, said that Wallace filed his latest complaint against the county on June 27, 2025. 

Yet, the memo continued, that lawsuit “essentially [contained] the same allegations in his prior lawsuit,” which Wallace filed against the county in 2024. Wallace voluntarily dismissed that complaint “after the County sent [him] several written discovery requests,” the OCA memo added.

The Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) already has “issued the necessary permit to operate the traffic signal,” the memo further noted.

Since the County Commission seated in December 2018 approved the Siesta Promenade mixed-use project on about 24 acres located at the intersection of Stickney Point Road and U.S. 41, Wallace has pursued a number of legal avenues to try to prevent the development from being constructed, contending that the extra traffic it will produce will result in long delays in travel time between south Siesta Key and locations off the barrier island. A stipulation of the County Commission in conjunction with its 3-2 vote was that the Avenue B and C stoplight be in place and operational before Siesta Promenade can open. 

In response to a Sarasota News Leader inquiry this week about the status of permitting for construction on the Siesta Promenade property, county staff wrote in a Nov. 17 email, “There has not been much activity on the site thus far. Some stormwater site work currently but that is about the extent of it.  A building permit was submitted for Phase 1 … but the permit has not been issued at this time. Therefore, no vertical development at this time.”

This aerial map shows the area where Siesta Promenade is planned, outlined in yellow. Image courtesy Sarasota County

On Aug. 20, the Florida Second District Court of Appeal acknowledged Wallace’s latest action, 12th Judicial Circuit Court records show.

Attorney Jordan Snyder, of the Hartsell Ozery law firm in Pompano Beach, is representing Wallace.

Already slow emergency medical response times for south Siesta residents

The brief filed for the appeal points out that the “traffic signal sits on Stickney Point Road, a designated constrained roadway for which the [Sarasota County] Comprehensive Plan directs the County ‘to not allow the existing operating conditions to be degraded.’ ”

The Comprehensive Plan guides growth in the community.

The brief continues, “This appeal asks whether the trial court erred in granting the motion to dismiss filed by Sarasota County thereby allowing Sarasota County to disregard its own Comprehensive Plan … without deciding [the issues] on a developed record.”

James P. Wallace IIIaddresses Siesta Key Association members in January 2019. File image

Wallace, 86, lives in a home in the 9100 block of Midnight Pass Road, the brief explains. He “is recovering from significant, continuing neck and back injuries, as well as surgeries,” it adds.

Because “of his age and condition,” the brief points out, “he is particularly susceptible to medical complications, including complications of heart disease and vascular deterioration, in which every minute of delay in emergency care matters.”

Yet, the brief notes, “Only two bridges connect Siesta Key to the mainland,” with the Stickney Point Road drawbridge “the primary route for ingress, egress, emergency medical transport, and hurricane evacuation. … Because of the location of his residence,” it continues, Wallace “relies invariably on Stickney Point Road,” even though the county’s Comprehensive Plan has designated the road as constrained. 

The brief explains that Future Land Use Policies 2.9.1 and 1.2.6 of the Comprehensive Plan say that Stickney Point Road operates at a service level of D, “where speed and freedom to maneuver are severely restricted and small increases in traffic cause operational problems.”

Noting that Sarasota County Fire Department data was attached to the amended complaint that Wallace had filed against the county in 2025, the brief adds that emergency response time to Wallace’s residence “is already slow.” From 2021 through 2024, the brief continues, “[E]mergency response [to south Siesta Key zones] took an average of 6:56 minutes, with a 90th-percentile time of 11:11 minutes …”

Further, the brief points out that “another 55 emergency responses took longer than 30 minutes and were excluded from [the data] as outliers.”

Moreover, it says, “Emergency transports of about eight miles from south Siesta Key to Sarasota Memorial Hospital averaged 12:53 minutes, with a 90th-percentile time of 22:25 minutes.”

Additionally, the brief notes that Fire Station 11, which is located on Stickney Point Road, northeast of U.S. 41, is 4.1 miles from Wallace’s home, “so emergency medical services must pass through the Subject Traffic Signal to reach him, [and] they are estimated to need an average of 7 minutes to do so,” with a 90th-percentile time of 12 minutes.

The red balloon on this aerial map marks the location of Fire Station 11. Image from Google Maps

Then the brief points out, “The Sarasota County Fire Department made an average of about 320 emergency medical trips per year from south Siesta Key to Sarasota Memorial Hospital over four years, nearly one a day. … [even though] Siesta Key has fewer than 400 residents over the age of 80, about 0.092% of the County’s population.”

It further notes that, in 2016, the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) “warned the County that the Stickney Point Road/U.S. 41 intersection was on its ‘High Crash Segments’ list, with crashes rising an average of 30% per year, PM peak level of service ‘F,’ and queues regularly reaching past the Stickney Point Bridge.”

The brief adds, “The public experiences the signal as a delay; [Wallace] faces a heightened risk to his life. That injury differs in kind, not merely in degree, from the community’s.” Attorney Snyder cited the 1958 Florida Supreme Court ruling in Boucher v. Novotny and the 1972 Florida Supreme Court’s order in Renard v. Dade County as the basis for that assertion.

The traffic signal itself

The brief further explains that county staff “has operational control” of the traffic signal at the intersection of Stickney Point Road and Avenue B and C, between U.S. 41 and the drawbridge. “Historically, the intersection was controlled by a stop sign on Avenue B & C, which imposed no delay on Stickney Point Road traffic; side street volumes are light and do not warrant signal control,” the brief adds.

“As proposed,” the brief continues, the signal “will run an 85-second fixed cycle coordinated with the 170 second signal at U.S. 41. Stickney Point Road through-traffic will face a red light for about 33 seconds of each cycle, and up to 47 seconds when pedestrians cross.” As a result, the brief says, “A licensed traffic engineer concluded that emergency vehicle preemption reduces but does not eliminate the resulting delay because emergency vehicles must still negotiate standing queues and conflicting traffic and that available side street detours either add time or do not avoid the added queues.”

County Fire Department chiefs have explained that department personnel use devices to turn red traffic lights to green, to hasten the travel of emergency vehicles.

Even though Wallace has objected to the County Commission in writing and in person about the inconsistency of the traffic signal with the Comprehensive Plan, the brief says, the county attorney has advised the board members that the plan’s provisions have “ ‘virtually no legal impact’ ” because of the state’s 2011 Community Planning Act. That law reduced the responsibilities of developers in regard to improving transportation systems that will be affected by residents of new neighborhoods.

Nonetheless, the brief points out, the Comprehensive Plan also has provisions related to the need for hurricane evacuation planning and disaster mitigation, including capping “the intensity of future development on them at the level allowed by zoning in effect on March 13, 1989. ‘Intensity,’ ” the brief notes, “includes ‘the measurement of the use of or demand on facilities and services.’ ”

Moreover, it says, with emphasis, “Future Land Use Policy 1.2.6 directs the County to discourage intensification within Hurricane Evacuation Zones A and B,” which are the zones most vulnerable to storm surge, such as those on the barrier islands.

The Comprehensive Plan also “provides that the County bears ‘an additional responsibility’ to maintain the existing level of service and ‘not allow the existing operations to be degraded,’ ” the brief points out.

Wallace has alleged that the operation of the new traffic signal “will further degrade existing conditions, increase emergency response and evacuation times, and is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan, the State Comprehensive Plan, and [Florida Statute 187.201],” the brief says, with emphasis.

Moreover, the brief points out, the state’s Community Planning Act gives the county’s Comprehensive Plan legal status. “Contrary to the County’s position,” it adds, Section 125.01 of the Florida Statutes “does not license the County to disregard the plan.”