Increase in Animal Services fees and fines to be considered by County Commission, in response to sheriff’s letter

Higher towing fees for Sheriff’s Office also proposed

Image courtesy Sarasota County Sheriff’s Office

This week, the Sarasota County commissioners asked the county administrative staff to work with Sheriff Kurt A. Hoffman and his staff on increasing fees that the Animal Services division of the Sheriff’s Office charges, along with fines related to Animal Services.

Further, at the request of Commissioner Teresa Mast, staff will collaborate with the Sheriff’s Office leadership on bringing back to the board a proposal for higher towing fees, to ensure that the agency can recover its expenses related to that work countywide.

Both motions passed unanimously.

As The Sarasota News Leader has reported, Hoffman sent a letter to County Administrator Jonathan Lewis on Aug. 31, suggesting that the fees and fines should be raised, as they had remained at the same level for the past 15 years.

Among the changes the sheriff proposed is raising the fee from $10 to $15 for the annual license for a dog or cat that has been spayed or neutered and increasing it from $25 to $30 for pets that have not been spayed or neutered.

He also called for increasing the registration fee from $100 to $500 for a “vicious animal” or “dangerous dog.”

County Administrator Jonathan Lewis brought up the sheriff’s letter during Lewis’ routine report to the board members as they conducted their regular meeting on Nov. 17. The issue has nothing to do with the Nov. 3 passage of Amendment 3, which will reduce county property tax revenue, Lewis pointed out. Hoffman had discussed it with him in the past, Lewis added. “It’s gotta be eight, nine, 12 months ago,” he said, noting that this “needed to be worked on.”

County Administrator Jonathan Lewis. File image

Before he asked his staff to review the proposal, Lewis continued, he wanted to make certain that the commissioners would like for him to do so. 

The new fees and fines could not go into effect without board action, he pointed out, which would come after the legal public notice of the recommended changes was provided.

The sheriff and other leaders of the agency were in the Commission Chambers, Lewis said, so they could answer any questions the board members might have.

(The commission was meeting in the new County Administration Center located at 1 Apex Road in Sarasota.)

Commissioner Mark Smith was the first to respond to Lewis’ remarks, saying, “You know, these are the types of things that we need to be looking at across the board …” He added that the fees should cover the costs incurred. “I’m in favor of moving this forward,” Smith told his colleagues.

“I’m definitely in favor of moving this forward,” Commissioner Mast said. 

Then she brought up the towing issue, explaining that that had “been brought to [her] attention through several conversations …”

Mast told her colleagues, “I’m not trying to do what I call a ‘gotcha,’ ” but if the towing fees are not covering the expenses the Sheriff’s Office incurs, “then we need to look at them and be very practical about the impact that we’ve been absorbing in the past.”

Chair Ron Cutsinger suggested the board members conclude the Animal Services discussion before tackling that one.

In regard to the Animal Services fines and fees, Cutsinger said, “This definitely needed to be updated,” noting that it had been “on the docket for a long time.”

“This isn’t generating a lot of revenue here,” he added of the sheriff’s suggested revisions. “What we’re doing is just paying for the cost of services that people receive.”

Commissioner Tom Knight, who served three terms as the county sheriff, did suggest that the board wait until the start of the 2028 fiscal year to implement the changes. 

“You could time it with the [start of the next] fiscal year,” County Administrator Lewis told Knight. 

This is a sampling of the current fines related to Animal Services. Image courtesy Sarasota County Sheriff’s Office

Then Knight noted that the Aug. 31 letter also proposed that the county budget pay for the expenses of the Special Magistrates who preside over hearings on disputes regarding actions taken by the Animal Services director.

Addressing Lewis, Knight indicated that Lewis could work with the sheriff on how to handle those expenses, adding, “That really doesn’t matter.”

Mast ended up making the motion for county staff to collaborate with leaders of the Sheriff’s Office on the revised schedule of Animal Services fees and fines, and Commissioner Smith seconded it. The vote was 5-0 in support of it.

As for the towing issue: Mast explained that it is her understanding that the fees for the towing of vehicles that have been involved in accidents — and in other types of situations — have not “been looked at in a significant amount of time.”

She added, “I want to make sure we’re cleaning house and making sure we’re not making any money off this. We’re just trying to keep the lights on and cover the cost. That’s it, period.”

She then made the motion for the revised towing fees to be brought before the commission at the same time as the proposed new Animal Services fees and fines.

That motion passed 5-0, as well.