No appeal of judge’s ruling in D.R. Horton case, County Commission decides on 3-2 vote, but Smith Properties purchase to be pursued

Commissioner Mast stresses value of Smith family land in flood protection measures

This aerial map shows the location of the Smith family’s property. Image courtesy Sarasota County

With Commissioners Teresa Mast and Mark Smith in the minority, the County Commission voted 3-2 on Nov. 17 to accept 12th Judicial Circuit Judge Hunter W. Carroll’s ruling early this month that Texas-based homebuilder D.R. Horton can proceed with a Live Local Act project on land next to the Celery Fields that is known as the Smith Properties.

Commissioner Tom Knight made the motion, with Chair Ron Cutsinger seconding it. New District 4 Commissioner Jim DeNiro joined them in the majority.

That motion further directed the Office of the County Attorney (OCA) “to pursue resolutions” of the other Live Local Act lawsuits that applicants have filed against the county, “including associated residual issues and continued defense,” as the OCA memo characterized that action.

The county had until Dec. 4 to file an appeal of Carroll’s decision, County Attorney Joshua Moye reported. Commissioner Smith was the only board member to state his desire to pursue an appeal. Commissioner Mast called it “very challenging” to accept either the option that most of her colleagues supported or an appeal.

Commissioner Teresa Mast talks about her desire for the county to purchase the Smiths’ property. News Leader image

On a second motion that Mast made and DeNiro seconded — which passed unanimously — the OCA will try to negotiate with D.R. Horton and the owners of the Smith Properties on an agreement for the county to purchase the land, or — alternatively — for the company to construct the least number of dwelling units possible.

“We’ll jump right on that,” County Attorney Joshua Moye told the board members after the vote.

Looking out at the audience at one point during the discussion, with her voice shaky, Mast said, “This has been a really stressful year for all of us. I have a personal plea [for] whoever [owns the land]: Please negotiate with us.”

She added, “This is near and dear to me … I love my county, but I love my backyard, and I love my neighbors. (She represents District 1, where the property is located.) “I’m pleading with you to please negotiate with us,” she repeated her earlier statement, “ ‘cause for me, it’s very personal.”

County Attorney Moye told the commissioners that he anticipated being able to provide them an update on the negotiations during one of their mid-December meetings. Those are scheduled for Dec. 15 and Dec. 16.

The Live Local Act lawsuits against the county followed the unanimous April 7 policy decision of the commissioners that such projects are not intended for property zoned for residential, rural or open uses. The Smith family land is zoned Open Use Rural.

The AG’s ‘amicus’ brief

A relevant issue that County Attorney Moye raised during his initial, Nov. 17 remarks on the D.R. Horton ruling was the fact that the Florida Attorney General’s Office had filed what is known as an amicus curiae — or “friend of the court” — brief in one of the other Live Local Act complaints filed against the county — the SITC case. (The registered agent for SITC is John “Jack” Cox III, president of Halfacre Construction Co. in Lakewood Ranch.)

Cornell Law School’s Legal Information Institute explains that the term amicus curiae “generally references a person or group who is not a party to an action, but has a strong interest in the matter. This person or group will petition the court for permission to submit a brief in the action intending to influence the court’s decision.”

Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier concluded in the office’s opinion “that the Live Local Act reflects the Legislature’s unequivocal determination that Florida’s shortage of affordable housing is a matter of significant statewide concern requiring a uniform response,” Moye told the commissioners. The brief added that “the county may not frustrate the Legislature’s judgment through administrative obstruction or misapplication of state law.”

Commissioner Tom Knight stressed that to his colleagues.

“In my time in government,” Knight said, referencing his three terms as county sheriff, “it’s very unusual to get a letter from the attorney general on situations like this. I’ve never seen that before. … Reading into [the opinion], that’s a clue.”

Cutsinger also told his colleagues that he was surprised by Attorney General Uthmeier’s amicus brief filing.

Concerns about high legal bills for the county

This engineering drawing shows the proposed layout of the D.R. Horton Live Local Act project. Image courtesy Sarasota County Government

During the board’s Nov. 17 discussion, Knight also talked of the total of 18 Live Local Act applications that county staff has received. If the county appealed the D.R. Horton ruling and lost, he pointed out, the county would end up paying $1.5 million in attorneys’ fees in the six cases that have been filed in Circuit Court against the county, based on a section of the Live Local Act that allows plaintiffs’ to recover fees up to $250,000 if they prevail in litigation. 

If some of those other developers filed complaints against the county in the aftermath of an appeal of the D.R. Horton case, Knight continued, according to his math, “We can end up at $4.5 million” in attorneys’ fees.

Moye acknowledged the potential of those fees, though he told Knight, “I’m not double-checking your math …”

Five other complaints are pending, he had reminded the board members.

Earlier during the meeting, the commissioners had discussed the county’s constrained finances in coming years because of the passage of the Florida constitutional Amendment 3, which will reduce property tax revenue starting in 2027.

Referencing the potential total legal fees, Chair Cutsinger said he could not support an appeal, “because we’d be sending good money after bad … with a negligible chance of being successful.”

In remarking on his motion after he made it, Knight also emphasized, “We … have to represent nearly 500,000 people that are paying into the bills that come along with this.”

Commissioner Tom Knight makes a point to his colleagues during the discussion. News Leader image

Further, he referred to the 40 members of the public — by count of The Sarasota News Leader — who spoke during the Open to the Public session of the meeting that morning, urging the board to appeal the ruling: “The people that were here earlier today — God bless ’em — we were looking out for them when we [took that April 7 vote]. We’re trying to protect our citizens from Tallahassee,” Knight continued. “The energy that they have should be [expended on] our [Sarasota County] Legislative Delegation in Tallahassee.”

Knight added of the Live Local Act, “It is the epitome of removing home rule, [with] Tallahassee … doing land use. We’re trying to protect our community,” he said, “and we lost.”

Knight also noted that, to his knowledge, the Sarasota County Commission was the solitary Florida county board to take the policy approach that was implemented in the spring. “We’re the only county to say, ‘We want to make decisions for our community,’ ” instead of the Legislature taking such action, he added.

“I think we took a pretty bold step,” Commissioner Cutsinger agreed. Yet, he continued, “We got a very clear response from the court on this. … The judge’s order is very unambiguous in terms of ‘We lost.’ ”

Cutsinger did offer plaudits for the work of the Office of the County Attorney in fighting the litigation: “That was excellent work product.”
Deputy County Attorney David M. Pearce handled the briefs.

A potentially smaller project, if the land cannot be bought

The direction in Mast’s motion related to the size of a potential community on the Smith family land reflected information in a Nov. 16 letter from attorney Charles D. Bailey III, of the Sarasota firm Williams Parker. Bailey explained in that letter that D.R. Horton still was willing to construct the 126 single-family home project that the commissioners unanimously rejected in February 2025, instead of the 864 apartments — in buildings up to 65 feet in height — proposed in the Live Local Act application. Bailey did point out, however, that the board would have to approve the necessary rezoning to make that smaller development possible, and that action would have to be completed “by the end of January 2027 in order for [D.R. Horton] to meet specific contractual obligations.”

County Attorney Moye had reported that offer, as well, during his opening remarks on the issues.

This is the Binding Development Concept Plan for the D.R. Horton community, presented during the Feb. 12, 2025 public hearing. Image courtesy Sarasota County

“We’d rather have 126 [units] than  864, for sure,” Chair Cutsinger told Moye.

Addressing the board on Nov. 17, Bailey noted that Judge Carroll also had conducted a hearing on a separate petition that D.R. Horton and the Smith family members filed with the court, in late April, seeking an order that the commissioners erred in denying the rezoning for that proposed new community.

A ruling in that case — styled formally as a Petition for Writ of Certiorari — remains pending after Carroll conducted oral arguments in October, Bailey told the board members. Carroll had requested direction on how to proceed with that petition, given Carroll’s Live Local Act ruling.

‘A once-in-a-lifetime opportunity’

During the approximately 45-minute discussion, Mast emphasized the “absolutely critical” value of the Smith’s land for expansion of the county’s Celery Fields Regional Stormwater Project. That would enable county staff to pursue efforts designed to broaden earlier county initiatives to reduce flooding in the surrounding area. 

She characterized that as “a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity …”

(Stormwater Director Ben Quartermaine had discussed that potential during a presentation earlier in the day, which focused on the commissioners’ 2026 priority of creating new “legacy” stormwater projects, akin to the Celery Fields.)

This is a view of the Smith family’s land on Aug. 5, 2024 after Tropical Storm Debby had rained as much as 16 or more inches on parts of the county. Image courtesy of Tom Matrullo

Residents have shown the commissioners photos they have taken of the Smith Properties underwater during storm events, including those that wreaked significant county damage in 2024.

Moreover, during the discussion about how to respond to Judge Carroll’s ruling, Commissioner Smith talked of the necessity of D.R. Horton having to bring in fill to raise the level of the Smiths’ land by 1 or 2 feet before any home construction could begin. 

A long-time architect, Smith stressed that raising the elevation of the site would result in the flooding of surrounding neighborhoods, especially during periods of heavy rain.

That “amount of dirt,” he emphasized, “is going to displace a tremendous amount of water in an area that we know floods.”

County Attorney Joshua Moye. File image

Yet, as he had during the board’s regular meeting on Nov. 4, County Attorney Moye explained that Judge Carroll’s ruling did not “decide whether the property satisfies other legal criteria. County staff must still apply the [County Code] requirements [that the Live Local Act did not pre-empt], through the site development and building permit processes.”

County staff has emphasized to the board members that county regulations require a developer to demonstrate through design work that a new community will not create flooding on neighboring lands.

Commissioner Smith also told his colleagues, “I don’t want to necessarily have the county in a position that [we are] willingly permitting a 126-unit subdivision on a place that is going to flood their neighbors. … However,” he continued, if D.R. Horton built the Live Local Act project, “We basically are free of liability as everyone gets flooded. We can say, ‘Well, you can thank the Legislature, and you can thank D.R. Horton.’ … Our hands are tied.”

Chair Cutsinger told his colleagues, “I would welcome an opportunity to have an honest discussion with the owners of the property … to determine … is there a way forward” in regard to the county’s willingness to buy the land.

Another reason that Knight cited for making the motion to accept Judge Carroll’s Nov. 4 ruling was that he said he understood that the purchase offer could not be discussed with D.R. Horton and the Smiths if the board members agreed to pursue the appeal. 

If they did choose to appeal, he added, “and we lose, I don’t think that that conversation will ever happen.”

After Moye completed his opening remarks on the D.R. Horton ruling, Mast did ask him about the status of the board’s recent direction for the Office of the County Attorney to convey to the company and the Smiths the board’s interest in purchasing the property.

He told her that he had contacted Sarasota attorney Bailey III, who is representing D.R. Horton, after the commission gave him that direction during its regular meeting on Nov. 4. “And we have not heard anything back” in response to that.

Nonetheless, Moye pointed out that Bailey was present, so the board could ask him to come to the podium to discuss that issue. 

After Chair Cutsinger agreed to let Bailey address the board, Mast told Bailey, “I’m not trying to put you on the spot, sir,” but she felt “it would be a worthwhile discussion for us to be able to know if your client would be amicable to having a discussion” about the potential county purchase.

Charlie Bailey addresses the board members on Nov. 17. News Leader image

Bailey responded that he had not discussed that with his clients, but he indicated a willingness to engage in such talks with them. 

Then Mast asked County Administrator Jonathan Lewis for confirmation that she had made a motion calling for the Office of the County Attorney to pursue the purchase negotiations with D.R. Horton and the Smiths.

Moye told her, “You did.”

Moye reminded Bailey that he had emailed Bailey on Oct. 6 to report that the commissioners had “voted down” the lawsuit settlement proposal regarding the 126-home subdivision and had inquired about buying the land.

The same day, Moye continued, Bailey replied via email, telling Moye that he would contact him, though Bailey added in his email — as Moye read it, “ ‘I am not sure my client contemplates a sale to the county as a desired outcome.’

“And that’s kinda where it got left,” Moye added.

“Fair enough,” Bailey responded, noting that he could not say that he recalled that, given all of the various issues he had been handling. Nonetheless, he continued, “Obviously, if it’s something the county wants to advance, we certainly would listen.”