Circuit judge vows to issue ruling as soon as possible

During Nov. 19 oral arguments in the 12th Judicial Circuit Court regarding a complaint that Protect Siesta Key filed in late September — to try to prevent the transfer of Sarasota County Government property standing at 162 Beach Road to Siesta businessman and property owner Michael Holderness — the nonprofit’s attorney stressed that the plaintiffs in the case have met the standard to be granted “standing” to pursue the litigation.
As Cornell Law School’s Legal Information Institute explains, “Standing, or locus standi, is the capacity of a party to bring a lawsuit in court. To have standing, a party must demonstrate a sufficient connection to and harm from the law or action being challenged.”
Robert Hartsell, of the Pompano Beach firm Hartsell Ozery, provided numerous details to Circuit Judge Hunter W. Carroll that, Hartsell maintained, showed that the organization itself and the four individual plaintiffs would be affected to an greater extent than the general public if Sarasota County proceeded with the land transfer to Holderness in return for three vacant lots that Holderness owns on the beach in the same general area.
The plaintiffs also contend that the county would be violating its Neighborhood Parkland Program (NPP) ordinance if it gave the Beach Road lot to Holderness, as the county purchased that property in 2017 for $1.4 million with NPP funds.

Formally, the hearing was held on the motions filed by Siesta Beach Lots’ attorneys and the Office of the County Attorney that called for Carroll to dismiss the Protect Siesta Key complaint with prejudice, meaning that Protect Siesta Key and the four individual plaintiffs would not be able to file an amended version of it in the court.
Representing Holderness during the hearing, former Florida Senate President Bill Galvano, an attorney with the Grimes Galvano firm in Bradenton, argued that the plaintiffs failed to assert sufficient facts to support their claim of standing.
Judge Carroll told the parties that he would “try to get this [ruling] out as soon as I can,” though he pointed out that he has conducted numerous other recent hearings for which he must issue orders, as well.
A months-long process
On Sept. 22, with Commissioner Mark Smith of Siesta Key casting the solitary “No” vote, the board members agreed to amended terms to settle a federal lawsuit that Holderness — through his limited liability company Siesta Beach Lots LLC — filed against the county in May 2024. Holderness had alleged that the county “took” his property near Beach Access 3 on Siesta Key through various means that invited the public to use it for recreation.
The settlement also included the County Commission’s approval in November 2025 of a Coastal Setback Variance that would allow Holderness to construct a single-family home on the 162 Beach Road property. That variance was necessary because the land is seaward of the county’s Gulf Beach Setback Line, which was established in 1979. The purpose of that line is to ensure protection of beach dunes and habitat which, in turn, protect landward structures during storms and other flooding events.
Commissioner Smith also was the only member of the board to vote against the variance.
‘The rare plaintiff’
Protect Siesta Key attorney Hartsell contended during the Nov. 19 hearing that, in this case, “You get the rare plaintiff … whose own person or property depends on the specific parcel at issue … The county’s own records say that [the lot’s] dune is shoreline stabilizing infrastructure.” He added, “The question is, ‘Who stands behind that dune that is being protected?’ ”
One of those individuals, he continued, is plaintiff John Phair, who lives in the Terrace East condominium complex “roughly 250 feet away” from the 162 Beach Road lot. “His unit overlooks the parcel,” Hartsell noted.

In Protect Siesta Key’s Nov. 17 response in opposition to the motions to dismiss the case, Hartsell wrote that the storm surge produced by Hurricane Helene produced several inches of water in Terrace East when the storm passed by the barrier island in late September 2024.
Hartsell stressed to Carroll, “Well, that’s exactly what we’re saying, your honor — that the flood … is proof of the exposure to the plaintiffs [of harm if the transfer of the parcel is allowed],” as the dune on the 162 Beach Road land did hold back floodwaters. “The injury happens when you strip that barrier,” he contended.
A second plaintiff, Mary Smarelli, also lives about 250 feet from the 162 Beach Road site, Hartsell said. “She’s watched the dune vegetation regrow since Helene, and she’s actually watched it impede floodwaters from reaching Beach Road” and her own property.
A third plaintiff, John Doherty, is disabled, Hartsell noted. “He uses a wheelchair.” Hurricane Helene’s flooding destroyed the “hand-controlled El Dorado that he’d spent months trying to find,” Hartsell pointed out.

Moreover, Hartsell said, after the county purchased the 162 Beach Road lot in 2017, staff said in 2018 that it planned an Americans with Disabilities Act parking area and beach access improvements on the land. “Staff designated it the Siesta Key Beach Access 4 addition.” Therefore, Hartsell continued, the conveyance of the property to Holderness would extinguish “a planned public accommodation of which [Doherty] is precisely the intended beneficiary.”
Lourdes Ramirez, the president of Protect Siesta Key and an individual plaintiff, and the other members of Protect Siesta Key qualify as having standing on the basis of the 1982 Florida Supreme Court decision in Fla. Home Builders Ass’n. v. Dep’t. of Labor & Emp. Sec., he added.
He wrote in the plaintiffs’ response to the defendants’ Motion to Dismiss that “Ms. Ramirez pleads sustained, particularized use and stewardship of [the 162 Beach Road] parcel’s immediate surroundings,” while Protect Siesta Key has “associational standing,” on the basis of its “identified members.”
At one point, after the attorneys had completed their arguments, plaintiff Doherty asked to address the court.
Doherty testified that residents of Terrace East other than the individual plaintiffs identified in the complaint also are members of Protect Siesta Key. “There’s 46 units in the building,” he pointed out, “and the average age is in the 70s, ranging all the way up to 90 years of age. So there’s a lot of risk in this issue …”
Hartsell also noted that county staff, in the report it prepared for the Nov. 5, 2025 public hearing on the Coastal Setback Variance for the 162 Beach Road property, wrote that construction of the residence with 4,190 square feet of living area, plus accessory structures ,“will likely increase stormwater runoff, and the proposed fill [that would be brought onto the property in advance of construction] may direct stormwater runoff and Gulf overwash toward neighboring properties or Beach Road.”

The county attorneys and Holderness’ attorney “cannot brand that as speculative,” Hartsell asserted.
An inadequate pleading of ‘special injury’
Galvano, Holderness’ attorney — who spoke first during the hearing — explained at the outset that the filing of the lawsuit “is an action to prevent the final consummation of a settlement of federal inverse condemnation that was mediated two years ago,” between Siesta Beach Lots and the county.
(Cornell Law School’s Legal Information Institute explains, “Inverse condemnation is a remedy for property owners when a government takes or damages a property for public use without having brought an eminent domain proceeding. To successfully bring an action for inverse condemnation, the property owner must show that the government’s taking has failed to promote substantial governmental interests or has deprived the owner of the economic value of their property.”)
In demonstrating standing, Galvano told Carroll, the plaintiffs had to provide factual allegations; those “cannot be conclusory.”
Moreover, Galvano continued, “The harms alleged are conjectural,” as they are based on the planned future construction on the 162 Beach Road parcel.
He also referenced the 2016 ruling of Florida’s Third District Court of Appeal in Herbits v. City of Miami, in which the development of a marina was challenged. The plaintiffs in that case, Galvano continued, “were complaining about [the] proximity [of the facility]. They were complaining about traffic. They were complaining about safety. They were complaining about environment, loss of open space and property values.”
He told Carroll that the Protect Siesta Key complaint “is replete with those type of allegations to try to establish a special injury, and I submit to you that that doesn’t get us there. Loss of open space, beach enjoyment, wildlife, coastal protection are all injuries shared by the public, just like traffic.”
Singling out plaintiff Phair, Galvano contended, “He’s a part-time [Siesta] resident. That’s not a special injury. He’s 250 feet away [from 162 Beach Road].”

Although Terrace East flooded during Hurricane Helene, Galvano added, that was in the past. Protect Siesta Key and the other plaintiffs have alleged future risk, “not a special injury.”
As for Doherty: Galvano cited the 2023 ruling of Florida’s Fourth District Court of Appeal in Citizens for Responsible Development v. City of Dania Beach, in which a plaintiff, who was legally blind, “said, ‘Look, with this increased traffic, I especially am going to be impacted,’ ” as Galvano paraphrased it. “And the court said, ‘No, that’s … not [a] special [injury].’ ”
Taking his turn during the arguments, Assistant County Attorney Neal Addison contended that the plaintiffs also had misinterpreted the part of the County Code that governs the county’s Neighborhood Parkland Program. Ordinance 90-68 “contemplates selling property,” Addison explained. “It’s disposing of property that the county has acquired for neighborhood parkland but turns out doesn’t really fit the criteria. As we point out in our motion,” Addison said, that ordinance is intended to apply to situations when the county purchases a parcel for the program and not all of the land meets the necessary criteria for the program. The county would be able to sell the portion of it that does not meet the criteria, he added.
In his Motion to Dismiss the Protect Siesta Key complaint, Addison wrote, “[N]othing in the text of Section 90-68 forbids the sale or exchange of the subject parcel. The language is permissive, and not prohibitive.”
In this case, Addison continued, the county is exchanging one parcel for three. “It’s a complete exchange of property,” he stressed.
Based on the language of Florida Statute 125.37 , he told Carroll, “Once the county says, ’In the opinion of the board today, this exchange is necessary for county purposes,’ that’s the end of it.”
He emphasized language in that state law that, he said, specifies “ ‘in the opinion of the board’ … regardless of whether it’s a good opinion, regardless if anyone agrees with it or disagrees with it; that’s all [Florida Statute] 125.37 requires.”